Same-Model AI Rendering Comparisons Still Need to Disclose Inputs, Prompts, Attempt Counts, Selection, Editing, Time Spent, and Failure Records
A same-model AI render shootout still needs its inputs, prompts, attempts, selection, edits, time, and failures disclosed.
A four-tool AI rendering comparison starting from the same SketchUp model is inherently unfair: plugins can read the real-time viewport and camera, browser tools only receive exported JPEGs, and real-time engines rebuild materials and scenes, so each product starts with different information. The article proposes a seven-item disclosure checklist—actual inputs, preparation work, instructions, attempt counts, selection rules, editing and failure records—and suggests listing preparation, waiting, correction, and export time along with credits consumed. The author also advocates distinguishing between "input-controlled image tests" and "workflow-native tests," arguing that scores from the two should not be combined.
Open original archigenai.com